Recruitment - Preventing Illegal Working Without Discrimination

Hardly a day goes by without there being some mention of illegal immigration in the news. The number of people discovered working here unlawfully has risen sharply in recent years.

There has been much talk of the possible introduction of a national identity card, but these are not likely to come in for some time.

For employers, the important issue when recruiting is how to avoid committing a criminal offence under the Asylum and Immigration Act 1996, by taking on someone not legally entitled to work in the UK, without falling foul of the Race Relations Act 1976, under which it is unlawful for an employer to discriminate on grounds of race, colour, ethnic or national origin or nationality.

An employer who employs someone who does not have permission to live and work in the UK can be fined £5,000 in respect of each person being employed illegally.

Any person who believes they have been discriminated against on racial grounds has the right to take their case to an industrial tribunal. If their complaint is upheld, there is no upper limit to the amount of compensation the employer can be ordered to pay.

There is a Code of Practice, issued by the Government, to help employers comply with both laws. Here is a summary of the guidance. A full copy of the code can be found on the Home Office website (www.homeoffice.gov.uk) under Immigration and Nationality, Employers' Information.

To be sure someone has the right to work in the UK and to establish a defence against possible prosecution you should ask a potential employee to provide an original document from a specified list. Examples are:

  • A document which gives the applicant's National Insurance (NI) number and name, for example a P45 or NI card;
  • Evidence that the applicant can stay indefinitely in the UK , or has no restrictions preventing them from working, such as an endorsement in a passport;
  • A work permit or other approval to take employment, issued by Work Permits UK ( part of the Home Office's Immigration and Nationality Directorate);
  • Evidence that the applicant is a UK citizen and has the right to live in the UK , such as a passport, birth certificate or naturalisation document;
  • Evidence that the applicant is a national of a European Economic Area country, such as a passport or a national identity card.

A complete list of specified documents can be found in the Code of Practice.

If you have any doubts as to whether a document is adequate for this purpose there is a special helpline to deal with enquiries on 0208 649 7878.

The best way to make sure that you do not discriminate is to treat all job applicants in exactly the same way at each stage of the recruitment process. Have clear, written recruitment procedures and check regularly that they are being followed. An employer can be held responsible for discriminatory action by employees, if they do not take steps to prevent it happening. You should:

  • Ask everyone if they need permission to work in the UK and ask all applicants for one of the necessary documents.
  • Don't insist on seeing a particular document. You don't have to see the NI number. All documents are of equal value.
  • Don't assume that a foreign national or an applicant from an ethnic minority has no right to work in the UK .
  • Don't assume that a person is an illegal worker if they can't produce one of the relevant documents. Suggest they go to a Citizens Advice Bureau for advice on what to do.
Keeping up with today's seemingly endless stream of new employment regulations is a real challenge, particularly for small to medium sized businesses. If you need advice or further information on how to avoid acting in a racially discriminatory manner, whilst making sure you have a defence against employing illegal workers, contact me, I will be happy to help you comply with the law.
View my profile
Louise Attrup
Executive Partner
T: 01727 735663 (DDI)
E:  
The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.

Latest News

In a recent case, Plymouth Hospital NHS Trust was ordered to pay compensat...
With only a couple of months to go before the London 2012 Olympic Games co...
When a developer sought to make use of a 37-year-old planning permission b...
The European Commission has published its framework for modernising data p...
A compromise agreement is a legally binding agreement by which an employee...
A worker who developed asbestosis after being exposed to high levels of as...
In general, rents on property are exempt supplies for VAT purposes. Howeve...
When the owner of a property failed to register a right of access, trouble...
The aggregates, cement and ready-mixed concrete industries are the latest ...
In Bivonas LLP and others v Bennett , the Employment Appeal Tribunal (E...
Computer programs have been at the centre of many legal disputes. Although...
When a member of staff is on a temporary assignment, they are allowed to r...
Currently, any employee who has completed one year of continuous employmen...
Problems with doing ‘clean’ business in some jurisdictions are...
The Localism Act 2011 is expected to come fully into force in April 2012...
On 1 January 2012 a new Pre-Action Protocol came into force to deal with t...
For businesspeople from outside the EU who do not have a commercial sponso...
The laws relating to defamation apply equally to material posted on the In...
As of 1 April 2012, all VAT-registered businesses must file their VAT retu...
When the co-founder of two companies in the wind farm business was effecti...
A landlord who receives a deposit from a tenant in respect of an assured s...
A Trafford firm has been fined £145,000 after an employee fell throu...
If your business infringes the Intellectual Property (IP) rights of others...
The Chancellor’s Budget this year was set in the context of mixed ec...
The Government has accepted the recommendations of the Low Pay Commission ...
When a financial services company went into administration and came under ...
The Government is carrying out a review of the current dismissal process a...
VEER DHARA RESTAURANT AND COCKTAIL BAR Get 10% off your total f...
In Zulhayir v JJ Food Service Ltd. , the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EA...
The banks are set to face claims for compensation running to many billions...
Owners of furnished holiday letting (FHL) properties are reminded that new...
Pharmacist removed from Register for theft from Pharmacy A pharmacist w...
The GPhC has launched a formal consultation on their vision for a safe sys...
When the construction of a village hall did not proceed as planned, the co...
31 March is a common year-end for companies and, with that in mind, compan...
The Government has confirmed that the qualification period for the right t...
A French firm that manufactures cosmetics and requires them to be sold onl...
The wisdom of making sure that agreements are finalised in good time and n...
When a company engages in below-cost pricing or other ‘predatory&rsq...
Each year, around 11 million employees take sickness leave. Of these, 300,...
HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) have recently set up a taskforce to investig...
When an adjudicator in a construction dispute gives a ruling, the decision...
The Government has announced its proposals for reform of the employment la...
Design rights are not the same as copyright, but are valuable intellectual...
When a dispute arises concerning the meaning of a contract term that is ca...
A recent case ( Whitham v Club 24 Ltd. t/a Ventura ) sheds further light o...
A consultation on ways of making it easier for social housing providers t...
HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) will be targeting 6,000 Swiss bank accounts ...
There has recently been a further case on long-term sickness and a worker&...
Creating a commercial database and keeping it up to date is an expensive b...
When a supplier to a marquee company was not paid for goods it had supplie...